Casselberry

Lakeside Seminole County living with strong commute access

Seminole County, Florida

Renting in Casselberry

Your Casselberry rental search starts from a concrete number: 30 active rentals are listed in this Seminole County market today, ranging from $950 to $2,747 per month. The area is defined by Lake Howell, Secret Lake Park, and Casselberry Golf Club. Waterfront and lake-view rentals are in demand here, so lakefront homes tend to lease quickly. Golf-community addresses such as Casselberry Golf Club draw their own steady demand.

The shape of the market is measurable: the mix leans toward single-family homes, condos, and townhomes, and two-bedroom and three-bedroom homes account for most of what is listed right now. Listings currently active here have spent an average of 44 days on the market.

Every matching Casselberry rental is in reach, whichever brokerage lists it, because NAH Rental Homes represents renters across the full Stellar MLS. Describe the home you want at TenantMatch and it builds the search for you.

Casselberry Market Snapshot

$1,750/mo
Median Rent
44 days
Avg Days on Market
30
Active Listings
2026-09-15
Last Updated

Live count from the current MLS rental feed; figures update as inventory changes.

About Casselberry

Casselberry sits at the southern edge of Seminole County along the 17-92 Orlando Avenue corridor and contains one of the metro's most extensive chains of urban lakes outside of downtown Orlando. The Howell Branch chain of lakes runs through the heart of the city, with Lake Howell, Lake Concord, Lake Triplet, and Lake Kathryn providing meaningful lakefront residential inventory and water recreation access. The residential inventory in Casselberry leans heavily on mid century ranch and split level construction from the 1960s and 1970s, with a growing layer of contemporary infill construction on tear down parcels along the lakefronts. Lot sizes typically range from quarter acre interior parcels to one acre plus lakefront parcels along Lake Howell and Lake Kathryn. The Lake Howell neighborhood east of Howell Branch Road features the area's strongest concentration of lakefront premium inventory. Deer Run, a 1980s era planned community at the southeastern edge of the city, features over 1,200 homes organized around the Deer Run Country Club golf course, with lots typically between quarter acre and half acre. The architectural inventory across Casselberry is varied, with Florida ranch, contemporary, and Mediterranean Revival construction all well represented. Commute access is strong: the 17-92 Orlando Avenue corridor runs north south through the heart of the city and connects directly to Winter Park, Maitland, and the Interstate 4 corridor; State Road 436 Semoran Boulevard runs east west and provides direct access to the 417 toll road and Orlando International Airport; and the 436 corridor itself anchors the city's primary commercial inventory. SunRail does not run through Casselberry directly, but the Altamonte Springs and Maitland stations are both reachable within ten minutes by car. Lake Howell Park, Secret Lake Park, and the Casselberry Recreation Complex anchor the area's parks and recreation inventory. The Casselberry Golf Club sits at the western edge of the city and features a public eighteen hole course on the site of one of the area's oldest golf operations. Pricing per square foot in Casselberry tracks meaningfully below Winter Park and Maitland but offers significant value for buyers seeking lakefront inventory within fifteen minutes of the Interstate 4 corridor. Lakefront parcels typically transact within weeks regardless of cycle. The Casselberry city government has invested heavily in roadway streetscape improvements along the 17-92 corridor over the past decade, with new sidewalks, landscaping, and gateway signage that has improved the visual character of the commercial corridor. Sellers preparing properties in Casselberry typically benefit from emphasizing lake access where applicable, lot size, and commute corridor proximity in marketing materials.

Notable Points of Interest

Housing Stock and Lot Pattern

Casselberry's housing stock skews toward mid century ranch and split level construction from the 1960s and 1970s, with a growing layer of contemporary infill on lakefront parcels and a meaningful pocket of 1980s era planned community construction in Deer Run. Lot sizes typically run from quarter acre interior parcels to one acre plus lakefront parcels.

Available Rentals in Casselberry

Showing 24 of 30 active rentals in Casselberry.

View all 30 rentals in Casselberry

Casselberry Map

Casselberry Rental Questions

How does renting in Casselberry work?
It works in three steps: you define what you want, tour the Seminole County rentals that match, and have NAH Rental Homes represent you through application and lease. Day to day, Casselberry is anchored by Lake Howell, Secret Lake Park, and Casselberry Golf Club.
What does it cost to rent in Casselberry?
The live feed answers this best: 30 active rentals in Casselberry, ranging from $950 to $2,747 per month. A static average would hide how much the property type and size move the number.
How do I start a rental search in Casselberry?
Start with TenantMatch, our intelligent intake at /tenantmatch. You describe the home you want in your own words, and it builds a precise Casselberry rental search, ranks the closest matches, and flags new listings as they appear.
Which places anchor daily life in Casselberry?
Casselberry is anchored by Lake Howell, Secret Lake Park, and Casselberry Golf Club, along with Deer Run Country Club and Lake Concord Park. These named places shape day-to-day life and rental demand.
Does NAH Rental Homes charge renters a fee in Casselberry?
NAH Rental Homes represents renters across the full Stellar MLS in Casselberry, and any renter-side terms are set out in writing in your tenant representation agreement before you tour. You see every matching rental, NAH-managed or not, with no ranking tricks and no surprise charges.

Looking to rent in Casselberry?

Whether you are starting your search or ready to tour, our team brings local market knowledge and tech-forward workflows to every move.